The Environmental Protection Agency released a Protocol for Developing the Fluoride Human Health Toxicity Assessment on Aug. 3, advancing an expedited scientific review that could ultimately lead to the most significant change to U.S. public water standards in decades.
The protocol defines the scientific methodology EPA will use to evaluate health risks associated with fluoride in drinking water, a step that precedes any potential change to the maximum contaminant level currently permitted in public water systems.
Fluoride is added to public water supplies serving approximately 73% of the U.S. population, a practice endorsed by major dental and medical organizations as effective in preventing tooth decay. The EPA review was placed on an expedited schedule following a 2024 federal court ruling that ordered the agency to act on a citizen petition challenging fluoride’s safety at existing concentrations.
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has publicly called for removing fluoride from drinking water as part of his “Make America Healthy Again” agenda, elevating the political significance of the EPA’s scientific review.
The toxicity assessment protocol establishes how EPA will evaluate existing research on fluoride’s effects on human health, including studies examining potential neurodevelopmental effects in children that have driven much of the recent scientific debate.
Any change to the fluoride maximum contaminant level would affect thousands of water utilities nationwide. Removing or reducing fluoride requirements could lower water treatment costs for utilities while potentially increasing dental health expenditures, particularly in low-income communities that rely most heavily on water fluoridation for dental protection.
The protocol release is a procedural step; a final toxicity assessment and any regulatory action would follow additional public comment periods and scientific review.